Description
The I Can’t Believe I’m Not Butter Shirt is smooth, comfortable, and just the right amount of ridiculous. This buttery yellow graphic tee is perfect for food lovers, pun enthusiasts, vegans, vegetarians, and anyone who wants their shirt to make people look twice.
Sizes Small through 4XL are printed on a Comfort Colors C1717 shirt in Butter. This premium garment-dyed tee has a soft, lived-in feel, substantial cotton fabric, and a relaxed unisex fit.
Size 5XL is printed on a Gildan G200 Ultra Cotton shirt in Cornsilk. The Cornsilk color provides the closest available match to the Butter Comfort Colors shirts while offering a comfortable and durable fit in an extended size.
I Can’t Believe I’m Not Butter Shirt Details
- Funny butter-inspired graphic shirt
- Warm butter yellow color
- Unisex fit
- Available in sizes Small through 5XL
- Comfort Colors C1717 in Butter for sizes Small through 4XL
- Gildan G200 Ultra Cotton in Cornsilk for size 5XL
- Comfortable cotton construction
- Professionally printed in Salt Lake City, Utah
Shirt Styles and Colors
Small through 4XL:
Comfort Colors C1717 in Butter
5XL:
Gildan G200 Adult Ultra Cotton T-Shirt in Cornsilk
The 5XL shirt is made by a different manufacturer because the Comfort Colors Butter shirt is not available in that size. There may be a slight difference in color, fabric weight, and fit between the two shirt styles.
Fit and Sizing
These shirts have a classic unisex fit. Check the size chart before ordering, especially when choosing between sizes or ordering the 5XL Gildan option.
Care Instructions
- Machine wash cold
- Wash inside out with similar colors
- Tumble dry low
- Do not iron directly over the printed design
- Do not use bleach
Order the I Can’t Believe I’m Not Butter Shirt for yourself or give it as a funny gift to the butter lover, foodie, cook, or pun collector in your life.





